OK, so Slate is only trying to keep you from getting laid if you’re trying to bed your child’s babysitter, but still.
I was somehow elected by DadWagon to take on this topic, I think out of some confusion: I said earlier that a previous babysitter had a crush on my son, not me crushing on the babysitter. And, really, I don’t know what the babysitter scene is like outside of New York, but we don’t really have barely-legal teen babysitter/cheerleader types in Gotham, so the whole American Beauty thing just doesn’t apply.
What does apply here and everywhere is that widowers raising children, like the dad who wrote to Dear Prudence’s column, are heroes. And heroes deserve to get laid (that’s why this woman slept with 300 NY Firefighters).
Here’s what the widower has to say about the babysitter, 24:
She just told me she has a serious crush on me and is restless in her relationship. She has also made feints into discussions about sex with me, which I’ve brushed away. She is very attractive, and I have been completely alone since my wife passed, so this is pretty awesome on about 100 levels.
Can you tell how happy the guy is? You can practically hear him smiling through his words. Not even a columnist with Prude in her name could rain on that parade, right? Wrong. Her answer, in part:
I’m afraid pursuing this young woman, awesome though it may sound, is a bad idea on about 100 levels… Hooray that your sap is running again. So use the motivation she’s provided you to start looking for someone more suitable to date.
Now, readers of DadWagon know that I have name-checked sex advice columnist Dan Savage before (though truth be told I doubt he knows/remembers me from our brief overlapping time at the Stranger). Savage sometimes gets a bad rap for advising people to break up too much. I don’t believe that, and I applaud him for doling out the best Valentine’s Day advice of the year this time around: dinner/wine/chocolate AFTER sex, not before. So simple! So smart! He deserves all the joy this unrelated but awesome news will give him this week.
Savage would, I think, have answered this differently. And I think maybe Prudie deserves a bit of a bad rap for keeping widowers from having sex. Yes, she’s usually somewhat measured and non-hysterical (although it’s easy to come off as sex-positive when your readers are concerned about mental adultery). But I disagree with her here: there’s no reason why sex couldn’t be good for both the dad and the sitter. Yes, it would complicate things. But sex and relationships are always complicated, and in this case there are no workplace harassment laws he’d have to deal with. She’s more than legal age, he’s more than deserving. Let them work out the sex/childcare conundrum in whatever manner they choose. Like adults.
Of course, in a week where Matt and the rest of us have been called cocksitters more than once, maybe I’m just unclear on what duties being a babysitter actually entails.